Effects of dam operation and land use on stream channel morphology and riparian vegetation
Introduction
Most river systems in the western United States are currently impounded to provide societal services such as hydropower, irrigation, flood control, and recreation (Graf, 1999, Graf, 2001). By regulating natural flow regimes and trapping sediment, an unfortunate trade off of dams is their potential to change historical channel dynamics and vegetation disturbances downstream (Dunne and Leopold, 1978, Simons and Li, 1980, Petts, 1984, Williams and Wolman, 1984, Chien, 1995, Brandt, 2000, Shields et al., 2000). Dams designed to actively control discharge for flood control are particularly effective at reducing peak discharge associated with storm events and increasing discharge during dry periods (Kondolf, 1997). The resultant loss of sediment load impounded behind dams and reduced discharge during storms can cause downstream channel incision and entrenchment, which may also lead to contractions in bankfull width and potential abandonment of floodplains (Cleveland and Kelley, 1977, Gurnell et al., 1994, Rosgen, 1996, Kondolf, 1997, Knighton, 1998, Brandt, 2000, Franklin et al., 2001). Accompanied by these changes, riparian vegetation along channel banks experiences less frequent flood disturbances, which can lead to an encroachment of increased vegetation abundance on the floodplain but with lower species diversity (Pelzman, 1973, Hupp, 1990, Hupp and Osterkamp, 1994, Friedman et al., 1998, Magilligan et al., 2003, Marston et al., 2005). These changes affect ecological processes in both aquatic and terrestrial riparian environments and are becoming an increasing concern in management and restoration of impounded river systems (Stevens et al., 2001, Thoms et al., 2005).
While dams play a critical role in stream channel processes, human land use practices such as agriculture and forest clearing can also impact fluvial geomorphic systems and riparian vegetation (Murgatroyd and Ternan, 1983, Osterkamp and Hupp, 1984, Mossa and McLean, 1997). Elimination of riparian habitat for agriculture can increase runoff, which can destabilize channel banks and vegetation establishment, cause channel aggradation, introduce fine-grained sediments (< 1 mm) that inhibit fish spawning habitat (Everest et al., 1987), and increase dissolved organic compounds (Thoms et al., 2005). Changes to historical discharge regimes and a channel's sediment transport capacity can contribute to periods of sediment deficit or surplus. During periods of surplus, aggradation may occur, resulting in increased bed eleation, bank narrowing, and/or bed fining, whereas periods of sediment deficit, with sufficient transport capacities, may lead to bed incision, bank widening, and/or bed coarsening (Carson, 1984, Bledsoe, 1999, Grams and Schmidt, 2005, Richard et al., 2005). Riparian vegetation is also an important factor in channel morphology and its distribution is affected by both discharge regime and land use practices adjacent to the channel (Hupp and Simon, 1991). Riparian vegetation influences channel adjustment processes by increasing bank stability, inhibiting erosion, and enhancing sedimentation for floodplain formation (Friedman et al., 1996). While the potential effect of land use on channel and vegetation dynamics have been increasingly explored (Knox, 1977, Martin and Johnson, 1987, Knox, 2001, Urban and Rhoads, 2003; see also, U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, 2005, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 2005), little is known about interacting effects of land use and dam operation. Empirically based studies are needed to differentiate effects of land use and dam operation on stream channel dynamics (Grams and Schmidt, 2005), but such data are typically difficult to obtain with sufficient spatial and temporal replication for multivariable analyses (Thoms et al., 2005). In addition, few studies have statistically examined the effects of a dam on channel and vegetation dynamics in relation to an undammed reference stream, a control for potential effects of climate change over the study period (but see, Stover and Montgomery, 2001, Grams and Schmidt, 2002, Grams and Schmidt, 2005, Thompson, 2006).
In this paper, we examine interacting effects of a northern California dam and land use on downstream changes in channel morphology and riparian vegetation that occurs along the watercourse. Spatial and temporal changes in planform channel morphology, riparian area, and land use adjacent to the channel are measured at multiple sites from a sequence of historical aerial photographs over a 34-yr period prior to operation of Warm Springs Dam in 1983 and over a 17-yr period after dam operation. Changes associated with the dam are also examined in relation to distance downstream of the dam and are statistically compared to a nearby undammed reference stream with similar climatic, geomorphic, and land use features. We corroborate these analyses using gauging station measurements and developed rating curves and performed hydraulic geometry exponent analyses to further examine stream channel dynamics and validate channel and vegetation changes interpreted from the air photos. Based on these data, we examined the following three questions:
- (i)
Does operation of a dam alter the spatial and temporal variability in channel morphology and the amount of vegetation in the riparian corridor, and to what degree does land use function as a contributing factor?
- (ii)
Does the rate and direction of changes in channel morphology and riparian vegetation differ after dam operation and does land use influence these changes?
- (iii)
Do field-measured hydraulics data correspond to air photo interpreted changes in planform channel morphology and riparian vegetation?
We hypothesize that the undammed reference stream will experience similar variability in channel morphology over the duration of the study period, while the dammed stream (Dry Creek) will experience significant changes in variability after operation of the dam. Specifically, we expect bankfull width to decrease as a result of reduced sediment loads and increased channel incision leading to an entrenched channel following dam operation; stream length will decrease from reduced episodic channel migration and less sinuous meandering in the entrenched channel, and riparian vegetation will increase in area because of less disturbance from reduced overbank flooding. In both dammed and undammed systems, we also expect agricultural land use along channels to encroach upon and reduce the area of the riparian forest vegetation during periods of reduced overbank flooding.
Section snippets
Study system
The Dry Creek watershed (672 km2), located approximately 120 km north of San Francisco, CA, is a major tributary of the Russian River watershed (3846 km2) (Fig. 1). Dry Creek has a Mediterranean-type climate, with a cool wet season from December to April (92 cm/yr) followed by a warm dry season with little to no precipitation. Substantial rain during the wet season in conjunction with a primarily gravel bed stream of Quaternary alluvium historically contributed to considerable flooding and
Methods
We examined interacting effects of Warm Springs Dam and land use on downstream changes in channel morphology and riparian vegetation distribution on the floodplain by using multivariable analysis. Changes in channel features and riparian vegetation were assessed from a series of historical aerial photographs from the dammed and undammed streams taken both prior to, and after the establishment of the Warm Springs Dam (1983). Dry Creek's morphological channel changes were corroborated using gauge
Bankfull area
The ANCOVA analysis of bankfull area variability (CV) shows that bankfull area varied similar amounts in both Dry Creek and the undammed reference stream during the pre-dam period (Fig. 5). Dry Creek's bankfull area varied 60% more during the post-dam period than during the pre-dam period (P = 0.0082; Table 2; Fig. 5), whereas the reference stream experienced the same amount of variation during both the pre- and post-dam periods.
The analysis of rate and direction of bankfull area changes (BKFA)
Channel, vegetation, and land use effects
Prior to establishment of Warm Springs Dam, unregulated peak flows and agricultural land use practices, including land clearing, promoted wide channels with a moderate amount of riparian forest vegetation along Dry Creek. Since operation of Warm Springs Dam, our data show that regulation of peak flows lead to reduced variability in channel morphology and a contraction in bankfull width. With less frequent flood disturbance, riparian forest vegetation expanded significantly along the channel's
Acknowledgements
We gratefully acknowledge Dorothy Freidel for her guidance in interpreting stream morphology. Nathan Rank was invaluable for assisting with statistical design. We sincerely thank J. Hall Cushman and David Stokes for their detailed comments that greatly improved this manuscript. Mathew Dietch was kind enough to provide archived USGS stream gauge measurements not readily available online.
References (60)
Classification of geomorphological effects downstream of dams
Catena
(2000)The meandering-braided river threshold: a reappraisal
Journal of Hydrology
(1984)- et al.
The role of vegetation and bed-level fluctuations in the process of channel narrowing
Geomorphology
(1996) - et al.
Stream flow regulation and multi-level flood plain formation: Channel narrowing on the aggrading Green River in eastern Unita Mountains, Colorado and Utah
Geomorphology
(2002) - et al.
Vegetation and channel variation: a case study of four small streams in southeastern Australia
Geomorphology
(1997) - et al.
Bank accretion and the development of vegetated depositional surfaces along modified alluvial channels
Geomorphology
(1991) Agricultural influence on landscape sensitivity in the upper Mississippi River Valley
Catena
(2001)- et al.
Channel response to increased and decreased bedload supply from land use change: contrasts between two catchments
Geomorphology
(2002) - et al.
Effects of Jackson Lake on the Snake River and its floodplain, Grand Teton National Park, Wyoming, USA
Geomorphology
(2005) - et al.
Channel planform and landcover changes on a mined river floodplain
Applied Geography
(1997)
Statistical analysis of lateral migration of the Rio Grande, New Mexico
Geomorphology
Channel change and flooding, Skokomish River, Washington
Journal of Hydrology
River meander and channel size
Journal of Hydrology
Perspectives on river channel restoration
Changes in river regime after construction of upstream reservoirs
Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
Erosion Along Dry Creek, Sonoma County, CA. California Division of Mines, Spec. Rep., Sacramento, California
A geomorphological justification of river channel reconnaissance surveys
Transactions - Institute of British Geographers
Water in Environmental Planning
Fine sediment and salmonid production a paradox
A comparison of hydrology and vegetation between a channelized stream and a nonchannelized stream in western Tennessee
Physical Geography
Downstream effects of dams on channel geometry and bottomland vegetation: regional patterns in the Great Plains
Wetlands
A geomorphic approach to the identification of river recovery potential
Physical Geography
Dam nation: a geographic census of American dams and their large-scale hydrologic impacts
Water Resources Research
Damage control: restoring the physical integrity of America's rivers
Annals of the Association of American Geographers
Equilibrium or indeterminate? Where sediment budgets fail: Sediment mass balance and adjustment of channel form, Green River downstream from Flaming Forge Dam, Utah and Colorado
Geomorphology
Channel planform change on the River Dee meanders, 1876–1992
Regulated Rivers: Research and Management
Response of Dry Creek, California, to land use changes, gravel mining and dam closure
Cited by (136)
Large-scale stresses, decay of River Jamuna and resilience strategies in the Anthropocene
2023, Quaternary Science AdvancesTemporal analysis of the planform morphology of the Quevedo River, Ecuador, using remote sensing
2023, Journal of South American Earth SciencesMacroinvertebrate assemblages downstream of dams show no sign of impairment despite flow regulation and thermal alteration
2023, Ecohydrology and Hydrobiology